Friday, January 25, 2013

Class 2 -- 1-22-13 Eating Disorders and Body Image Issues

1-22-13  Thoughts, Questions, and Reflections on Eating Disorders and Body Image

Have you known someone with an eating disorder?  What do you think this is all about?  Is there a role for us as pharmacists or women?  It is a complex area and requires a lot of understanding.  Long term complications can be alterations of the GI tract/ esophagus and of course - associated osteoporosis. 

From your food diary (My Fitness Pal for example) are you getting a  balanced diet or are you a little low on a micro nutrient?

What would you say to someone who asked about weight-loss products in the pharmacy?

[you are not obliged to discuss all of these - they are simply a prompt to get you thinking or discussing]   Remember for class 1/29/13 to read the Mass marketing and Eating Disorders posted on  Blackboard.

8 comments:

  1. I have known someone who had an eating disorder. She was one of my good friends from high school. It all started our freshman year of high school and she had trouble adjusting to the new setting. From my experience with her, I think eating disorders revolve a lot around social pressure and stress. There is this need to maintain a certain image. The media and society continue to tell us that being skinny is the ultimate sign of beauty. What the media and society should be stressing is the importance of practicing healthy habits and having a positive body image. For pharmacists, I think we do have a role in educating patients about healthy habits. Unfortunately, I don’t think pharmacists have quite as much impact on educating teens who are most at risk for eating disorders. Most of the patients that walk into the pharmacy are adults, so I think pharmacists can have a bigger impact on improving the health of adults. I would love to see retail pharmacies expanding to talk more with patients on discussing how their medications and lifestyle changes can work together to improve their quality of life. For patients who ask about weight loss products, I would help them with whatever product they are searching for, but also let them know that weight loss products can't take the place of dieting and exercising. I would also emphasize the importance of a balanced diet and exercise for the long term benefits.

    ReplyDelete
  2. After class, I downloaded the myfitnesspal app to play around with it and see what it was all about. I was actually quite impressed with it. However, one thing I did not really like was the way it presents some of the nutrient statistics. When you go over your daily target of a nutrient, it shows the excess in red which is beneficial for those nutrients where excess is harmful such as saturated fat, cholesterol, etc. However, it also shows up as red if you have more dietary fiber and unsaturated fats for example than the goal, though having more of these than the low pre-set app goal is not necessarily a bad thing. I think to the average user, it may signal them to cut back on fiber-rich foods or those heart-healthy fat since the value appears in red, even though they are not necessarily "bad nutrients" to have. Though the user can manually change these goals, without proper education, the goals they set may not be appropriate. Overall, I think the tool is very beneficial but we also need some education to go along with the application.

    I also think education is extremely important to supplement this app so that people also do not get too obsessed with the app and tracking their foods. After researching these apps online, I found blogs about people trying to limit their calories so much that they weren't reaching their calorie goal that was set by the app. This worries me in that people can take this app to the extreme to try to find how little they can eat, thinking it will help them lose weight when in reality, that sets them up for starvation mode in which the body is going to try to hold on to fat rather than burn it as energy. So I think there is a delicate balance that is needed between using the application and receiving proper nutrition education so that these technology tools that are intended to help don't in turn contribute to unhealthy eating habits.

    As far as weight loss product recommendations, I would assist them in finding what it is they are looking for, though warn them about their efficacy (or rather lack of-- if they really worked, then we really shouldn't be experiencing an obesity problem) and stress the importance of proper nutrition and exercise. I think I would suggest phone apps as a tool though be sure to provide education and limitations of the application. I would also stress communication with their doctor before starting any weight loss product to be properly monitored throughout the process and be able to catch on to any issues including disorders if they take weight loss to the extreme.

    I also wish more girls could see and hear from people who had an eating disorder to show them that starving yourself is not going to get you where you plan for it to and just how harm you put your body through. Osteoporosis and other complications often get swept under the rug...

    I also thought it was interesting when we discussed that similar to amputees dreaming that they still have their missing limb, patients who were once overweight and have now lost weight still see themselves as the larger version. I remember watching an episode of Say Yes to the Dress where a future bride had lost about 75 pounds, was now about a size 2 or 4, and pretty much could pull off any style of dress she wanted to. Yet, she wasn't able to find a dress - not because everything looked good and she couldn't choose one, but rather she thought she looked fat in all of them. I remember watching this, thinking how can she seriously think she looks fat? Is she crazy? But body image and weight is such a complex issue and it's different for every person which is why it's a hard topic to address.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The first time I was exposed to eating disorders was in high school. A girl on my cross country team developed anorexia. To me, it seemed to be fueled by performance and not necessarily social ideals. It was hard to watch a friend go through that and I realized that until she decided she wanted to change, there was nothing anyone could do short of providing advice and counseling. I remember feeling sad when she started to race better at such a low weight, it was like negative reinforcement and turned her disorder into a vicious cycle. I think if I could go back, knowing what I do now, I would have tried to tell her about all of the complications she was putting herself at risk of and maybe that would have sunk in.

    Once I started running in college, I noticed that eating disorders were much more prevalent than they were in high school. It is a hard balance between being fit and too thin. Most of the college runners I know were healthy and maintained great eating habits; however, I know a few who took restrictive eating habits too far. I think growing up in a sport where weight was an issue, I learned that you have to be comfortable in your own body and not feel pressured by other people, coaches, or parents. I think that in sports like running or wrestling, coaches have to be proactive to prevent eating disorders.

    Switching topics, if someone asked me for a weight loss product in the pharmacy, I would first ask questions to figure out if a supplement was necessary. Knowing how much weight they wanted to lose, how much weight they had gained, and how did they put the weight on would be useful in making a recommendation. I would be hesitant to recommend a diet supplement because short of Alli, most OTC supplements are not FDA approved and carry significant cardiovascular risk. I would push exercise and proper eating habits such as maintaining a food log, and drinking water instead of soda. I think that if a person is trying to lose weight it should be a lifestyle change.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have also known people with eating disorders. I think eating disorders are a difficult thing to talk about with people you may be concerned about because you don't want to offend them, but it's such a serious issue that has real, serious consequences. One of my friends from high school went to an out-of-state rehab facility to get treatment. I think none of my friends at the time really understood how her eating disorder could so negatively affect her health. It's not just a psychological issue. Personally I think it would be beneficial to show a similar video to the one we watched to young teenagers so that they can better understand the physical consequences of eating disorders. Maybe it could help people get treatment earlier.

    One thing that really stood out to me from the video was when they monitored the gastric emptying rate of the woman who had bulimia. This made me wonder more about this subject, and I found an article from the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/56/4/656.long) that described how binge eating in bulimics, who have initial delayed gastric emptying, enlarges gastric capacity, which then creates positive feedback that allows them to have larger binges over time. There was a strong correlation between how much the women ate and how much their gastric capacity was determined to be. Basically, the delayed gastric emptying rate further perpetuates the ability to binge.

    Like Katie, I also started using MyFitnessPal after class. I had the same thought that the "red" for exceeding the goal always comes across as a negative, while in many nutritional cases it is a good thing to exceed a goal. I agree that this is an area of the site that needs to be improved. On the positive, I do think that it is very beneficial for people to help become more aware of what they're putting into their bodies. I have already become better enlightened about the nutritional content of certain foods/(Starbucks drinks) that I consume fairly often. When used correctly, I think the site is very helpful to lead a healthy lifestyle.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I, like probably all the other women in this class, have known friends that have suffered from an eating disorder at some point in their life. I watched as they struggled to achieve this “ideal” image of what their body should look like and I knew that their actions were wrong. However, the video we watched in class really opened my eyes to just how damaging eating disorders can be on the body. I did not realize a person with anorexia could develop such extreme osteoporosis at a young age. The bone density scans in the video were devastating to me. The images that depicted the differences in gastric emptying in a recovering bulimic also shocked me. I wish the youth of today could see those pictures and understand the life-altering complications associated with anorexia and bulimia. I have three teenage cousins who are all having a rough time going through high school right now; I am extremely worried they are going to turn to an eating disorder in order to meet an image of beauty that is, quite frankly, unattainable. I am definitely showing them part (if not all) of the video in the hopes that they will better understand the implications of anorexia and bulimia.

    The video also made me think about how we as a society intend to treat anorexia, bulimia, and obesity. None of the women shown in the video had a great grasp on a healthy lifestyle. Rachel, the plus-size model in the video, battled with anorexia for years before she finally “beat” her illness. But look where Rachel is now; she is definitely not healthy or a normal weight. Instead, she went from one eating problem to another. I love that Rachel loves her body and thinks that she is beautiful but is that enough? Shouldn’t we all strive to not only feel comfortable in our skin, but also be healthy? How does a person achieve this delicate balance without becoming anorexia/bulimic or overweight/obese? I don’t know how we as health care workers help our patients (and ourselves) master this challenge but something needs to be done.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My freshman year roommate in Ross Hall had an eating disorder. For the longest time I did not realize it. One day I realized that she was counting every calorie she was eating and would skip meals several times. I would always try to get her to come to lunch with me to make sure she was eating. The reason it started to concern me was because she was already so thin to begin with I did not want her to get any smaller. She ended up transferring schools after that year, so I am not for sure if she is still like that or not. I guess the hardest thing for me was to understand why she even needed to watch what she was eating in the first place or work out an excessive amount. However, I was the complete opposite of that (meaning I would not skip a meal and loved late night snacks) so it was hard for me to understand what she was going through.

    Over the past 5 years I have put on some solid weight and have started to watch what I eat. I have been using MyFitnessPal off and on for the past 2 years (more off than on). I am starting to want to get back down to a healthier weight now, so MyFitnessPal has been my best friend for the past month and it has already helped me to lose weight and get on track with which nutrients I need. I think it is one of the best free apps out there for anyone just to keep a person on track to make sure they are getting their required nutrients and not necessarily to lose weight.

    I guess the biggest thing I've learned from this past week in class is that many people do not actually realize how badly anorexia can affect your life and body in the future. I would be sure to not recommend major weight loss products especially for someone who is only moderately overweight. I think the best thing you can say is to just recommend reducing your fatty meals and fast food dinners and to be sure to get a healthy workout in your day.

    ReplyDelete
  7. When I was in sixth grade one of my close friends developed bulemia. She was hospitalized for a couple of days and her mother was threatened by CPS. In her case it was pressure from her mother to fit the supermodel look. Her mother made her tan at least three times a week even though we were barely 12 years old and she had to watch what she ate or she was required to run on the treadmill. I think it also stemmed from the fact that she was much taller than everyone else and her self esteem was already very low from her mother's berating comments. As we have grown older I doubt very much if things have changed for her because she is still grossly thin. I don't think that community pharmacists are close enough to patients to notice most cases like this, but maybe if a pharmacist had talked to her during her hospitalization she would have understood that not eating is effecting more than just her weight and appearance.

    I started using MyFitnessPal about three weeks ago. I cut down on my caloric intake significantly as I was eating close to 3000 calories a day :). I also realized that I am not eating much protein because let's face it meat is expensive and I am cheap. After noticing my vitamin intake is low and watching the video I have been taking a calcium and iron supplement daily.

    when someone comes into Wal-mart asking about weight loss products I tell them a little bit about them before telling them where they are. I make sure they know about the side effects of Alli, because after living with a girl who had the worst part of those, I don't think anyone would want to discover the side effects naturally.

    Going back to the video, I didn't realize just how damaging eating disorders are to someone's health. I knew you could get thinning hair and brittle nails, but the osteoporosis and heart complications were surprising. I think a great area for pharmacists to branch out into community service would be to provide free education to junior high students. Maybe a group discussion with the entire class like they did for our sex ed.

    ReplyDelete
  8. We had mentioned last week in class whether males would have a similar decrease in hormone levels as females with anorexia or low body weight. I did find two articles looking at testosterone levels, the first in anorexic males and the second is looking at both bone mineral density & testosterone levels in long-distance runners.
    http://jcem.endojournals.org/content/86/7/2982.full
    http://bjsportmed.com/content/34/4/273.full.pdf+html

    It appears that there can also be a decrease in male testosterone as well, likely from a similar mechanism of the male having a lack of fat in their body to produce testosterone.

    Like Katie, I have also seen a few episodes of Say Yes to the Dress that dealt with females struggling with body issues. We may view clips of these today in class.

    ReplyDelete