• The American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery
reported the Top 5 Cosmetic Surgical Procedures for women in 2011 were breast
augmentation, lipoplasty, abdominoplasty (tummy tuck), blepharoplasty (cosmetic
eyelid surgery), and breast lift. The
number of cosmetic procedures for women increased over 208% from 1997. $6.3
billion dollars were spent on surgical cosmetic procedures in 2011 and 79% of
the procedures were performed on Caucasians (9% Hispanics, 7% African American,
5% Asians, 1% other). (see http://www.surgery.org/media/statistics
for more statistics if interested)
Based on the article you read for last
class and the movie America the Beautiful, in what ways do you think the media
has influenced the increasing numbers of cosmetic procedures?
Do you believe individuals reading magazines
recognize that the majority of these images are altered by photo shop?
What are some reasons that Caucasians
accounted for the large majority of the cosmetic procedures performed in 2011?
What were your thoughts on a 12 year old girl modeling for women’s clothing
lines? Feel free to add any additional
thoughts/questions from what was discussed or presented in class on Tuesday.
Of note, some insurances not only will not cover plastic surgery, but will also not cover any complications of the surgery as Dr.VanTyle mentioned in class. An important distinguishing factor in whether or not insurance will cover the procedure is whether it is considered "reconstructive" or an "elective" surgery. A reconstructive surgery will help to improve function such as receiving a breast reduction for low back pain. Reconstructive surgeries are generally covered whereas elective surgeries are not.
ReplyDeleteThis first article I found talks about a potential coverage option for someone undergoing an elective surgery: http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/complications-from-plastic-surgery-insurance-program-152736295.html
The second link outlines insurance coverage for complications of an elective surgery by UnitedHealthCare. This is one company that I found that will cover complications from an elective surgery (though does not cover the surgery itself). Note that many insurances do not cover either.
https://www.unitedhealthcareonline.com/ccmcontent/ProviderII/UHC/en-US/Assets/ProviderStaticFiles/ProviderStaticFilesPdf/Tools%20and%20Resources/Policies%20and%20Protocols/Medical%20Policies/Medical%20Policies/TX_of_Complications_CD.pdf
I think the media is out of control with what they deem as acceptable to publish. I did not realize until watching the movie that 99% of all images in magazines were altered; I knew some of the pictures were photo shopped, but I had no idea of the extent. I believe most women had a similar opinion. What is worse is that the magazine companies and other media outlets do not want to take the blame for how women are represented. In the film we watched on Tuesday, each media CEO blamed someone else for the awful way women are depicted. They often said that if they didn’t photo shop anything and took out all the harmful ads, someone else would have an ad degrading women elsewhere, whether it be on a billboard or in another magazine. Until the varying media outlets ban together and recognize this as a problem they can fix, we as a society will be forced to look at “fake” women who have bodies and faces that are unattainable.
ReplyDeleteThe plastic surgery segment of the video also amazed me. I was extremely surprised by the number of minors who receive plastic surgery in the United States every year. I don’t understand why these individuals want to change their bodies before their bodies are fully developed. I think the media is, in large part, to blame for this practice. However, I also believe the medical community is somewhat at fault. We constantly label people into categories based on weight, race, age, etc.; I know these categories are necessary (especially for us as pharmacists with dosing), but some days I think we have gone too far. I did a little research and came across an article that was printed in the UK early this week that looks at this issue. The authors of the article suggest that health care professionals need to take a step back and look at the way we address patients. They suggest physicians, nurses, and other members of the health care field stop using words like “better” or “enhanced” and switch to words like “bigger” and “smaller” (the article focused on plastic surgery). This brings up an interesting point: the words we use to describe treatments on/for the body definitely resonate with our patients. They take these words to heart and believe them.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/9833321/Dont-promise-women-they-will-be-more-beautiful-cosmetic-surgeons-warned.html
Like Blaire, I was so disappointed by the comments made by the editors and advertising directors of magazines regarding advertising. They think that girls can simply turn the page if they do not like what they see. But I think they are totally ignoring the subliminal messages that are sent to the readers regarding photo-editing. Personally, I know that many (and according to the video, just about all) of the photos in the media are edited. But when I am looking at a picture in a magazine, I am not always fully applying that to what I see. It is extremely difficult to be able to separate the image I am looking at from what in reality I should be seeing. Instead, the reader is left with an idea of what they should look like which is unobtainable as it doesn't even exist in reality. So even though readers may literally know the photo has been edited, when we physically view the picture, I think that knowledge gets pushed deeper into our brains and the reader does not fully make the connection that what we're looking at doesn't actually exist.
ReplyDeleteThen there's the issue of having a 12-year-old model for women's clothing. It is sort of related to photo-editing. I will never look like that model either a) because the photo was edited or b) the model has not hit puberty and is not an accurate portrayal of the women to whom the clothing is marketed. Again, it is putting the message out there that we need to be something that doesn't exist/isn't possible, yet creates the drive for girls to try to accomplish that.
I also thought the plastic surgery rates were appalling, especially on girls so young in age. I was also so shocked when the mother of that girl who wanted to be a model said she would be willing to pay for liposuction for her 15 year old daughter since she wanted to be a model…
I agree with the girls above. I definitely think that the media sways the public's opinion of beauty. Magazines like Cosmo, People, and Us Weekly, all feature celebrities who are thin, with perfect hair and skin. For as much as these magazines showcase the "beautiful," they also condemn stars who have gained weight or who have taken a bad photograph. I think the combination of praising the unrealistic and poking fun at images that most of the general public could relate to contributes to society's warped view of beauty.
ReplyDeleteWhen I read a magazine, I can often tell when a woman on the cover was retouched. However, even though I can recognize this it still makes me feel a little self-conscious about my own faults. I think that is because I also recognize that, while not real, this is what society was taught to find beautiful.
For young girls these magazines and TV shows such as "Real Housewives," promote plastic surgery. This can be very dangerous. Of course there are physical risk to surgery but I think the greater risk is the psychological harm that young girls put themselves through to achieve an unreachable ideal. It is important for the media to expose the public to healthy positive images. I don't think it is reasonable to say they cannot retouch images, however, if the magazines featured women of all sizes, races, and demographics, it may help the public to see others, and themselves, as beautiful.
As for allowing a 12 year old to model, I don't think the problem lies with the child's parents, I think it lies with the industry. There seems to be a disconnect with clothing manufactures and the general population. Why make clothes for a 30 year old woman and model them with a 12 year old girl? It continues to set a standard that she will never achieve, nor should she try to. I believe industries should have age limits on the models they hire.
I believe that most adults and older teens realize the images are photo shopped but may not realize the extent to how much they are altered. I definitely didn’t realize how much pictures and ads were photo shopped. When I was younger, they always just looked so perfect…I thought it was natural. As I got older and with seeing the Youtube videos, I realize just how fake those ads and pictures are. They present girls with these “perfect images” to sell a product. If a make-up company puts a picture of a girl that has a few blemishes on her face, what motivation would that give girls and teens to use that product? I believe it is a wonderful idea to put a special note on pictures or ads that have use photo shop on the models. At least it’s a step in the right direction of trying to educate young girls and teens about body image.
ReplyDeleteI don’t think it’s right to allow a 12 year old girl to model. Based on the movie, it seems like modeling was stealing her childhood. At a young age, she is not only being influenced by magazine pictures of photo shopped women, but she is also being influenced first hand by the models and agents apart of her modeling jobs. You hear about agencies telling their models that they need to lose 10 pounds to get a particular job. Most models are older and understand that it’s not uncommon to be told to lose weight. Most 12 year old girls wouldn’t know how to react to being told they need to lose weight.
I was previously aware that virtually every magazine image is altered by photoshop. It is astonishing to me, however, that magazine editors think that young women have the ability to put these images into another category in their brains as "photoshopped" and not something realistic. Even IF every woman and girl understood that every image is photoshopped, she is still going to see that image and recognize it as the way society wants women to look. It is still being broadcast to society as the ideal. I don't think it would matter if everyone understood that it is an unreachable goal, because these magazines are making so many women strive for an impossible perfect, which often ends up with women developing unhealthy consequences, such as anorexia. I also agree with what others have said above on this subject.
ReplyDeleteI think that there are multiple reasons Caucasians accounted for the majority of cosmetic procedures in 2011. First, many Caucasians have more of the financial capabilities to undergo elective, cosmetic surgeries than many minorities. Second, as we discussed, the vast majority of models shown in the media are Caucasian. I think this may make more Caucasian women prone to wanting to change parts of their bodies to fit the "ideal body image". I'm not saying that this is not also a problem with minorities, just that there might be different ideals based on race.
I think that the media has largely influenced the increase in cosmetic surgeries. Companies want women to buy their products. So they target women's "flaws" and tell them that if they use a certain product, it will "fix" that flaw and they too can be beautiful like said model. But when women buy so many products and never see results like they are told to expect, they may decide to undergo surgery to finally change one part of themselves to be like the ideal woman. And I think that many times once a woman undergoes one elective surgery, she is much more likely to undergo additional cosmetic surgeries. It becomes an addiction to striving for an unattainable ideal, and I think in a way this is similar to women who struggle with disorders like anorexia. These women feel like no matter what they do to their bodies, it is never enough.
Based on the article and the movie, I would say that many women are influenced by the media based on what the media portrays as "beautiful." Many women compare themselves to women who are famous. Most of the women who are famous alter their bodies through plastic surgery. Therefore, I believe that women feel the need to get these plastic surgeries to look like supermodels. I think they want to look like supermodels because they feel that it will make them more desirable to men. In the movie, the men described wanting girls who are thin or pretty. However, I believe that is not the case with all men. I think if they would have shown a better variety of men in the video you would see that guys like all kinds of women. Women will constantly be self conscious about their bodies; however, I agree with African women who said you should "love your body". Once you can love your own body, the confidence will show and it will make you more desirable and happy.
ReplyDeleteI think that many younger girls do not realize that images in magazines have been photo shopped. However, I do think that older teenagers or adults know they have been photo shopped, but still forget about it when looking at photos. Many times I have seen a photo and been like, "wow, i wish my _____ (whatever body part) would look like hers." Then it takes me a minute to realize, and accept that it is unrealistic and unhealthy to be that tiny. I know that it is unrealistic for magazines to stop photo shopping, but I do think there should be some type of disclaimer in the younger teen magazines. Now a days, it seems that girls younger and younger are starting to diet and try to look older because of the women they see in these magazines. Therefore if there was some type of disclaimer in the magazine maybe some awareness could start to spread and help these these girls to learn to love themselves for who they are.
I think that the media not only influences women to undergo plastic surgery, they encourage it. If you look at any tabloid you are going to see a lot of articles based on weight and beauty. In Seventeen and Cosmopolitan it is very common to have a lineup of celebrities and then the magazine will tell you what they think is wrong with them: her hair is too dark, her makeup is too light, her teeth need bleached, she has love handles…. Current issues for these magazines are more and more about tearing down the self esteem of women than anything of substance. It is rare when a fashion magazine doesn’t have something negative to say about any given person.
ReplyDeleteI didn’t know that almost every photo in magazines undergoes photo shop either. I knew that a lot of celebrities had their cellulite erased or a blemish covered, but I had no idea that they usually adjust their weight. The video showing the “normal” girl getting her legs and curves photo shopped was a bit of an eye opener. I do not think this is common knowledge as the media executives claimed.
As far as Caucasian women leading the way for cosmetic surgeries, I think it has a lot to do with the fact that most magazines are only tearing down Caucasian women. It is much more common for other ethnicities to be ignored than analyzed. This might be a fear of a discrimination lawsuit or just the fact that other ethnicities are more proud of their cultural beauty and are not interested in these articles. I do know that when as cosmetic surgery becomes more culturally acceptable, young girls are going to keep using it as a self esteem booster. I know two girls that took out college loans their freshman year to get breast implants. Both girls were beautiful before but they claimed their breasts were disproportionate to their body.
The 12 year old girl modeling disgusted me. As a former model, her mother should have known there would be people out there staring at her pictures lustily. If she was wearing more age appropriate clothing it would not have been as big of deal, but when pictures of her butt hanging out of her shorts were sent to the general public it became inappropriate. It is hard to imagine how getting dropped from the modeling scene has affected her self esteem now.