Saturday, March 23, 2013

Class #9 - 3-18-13 Heart Disease in Women

We discussed heart disease in women and had a guest come share her experience with heart disease.  Is there more you need to know?  Do you understand the difference in presentation between men and women?  We're you aware that women have a worse outcome from the first heart attack than men?  This is one area that I think you can really see the effects of the FDA rule prohibiting Women in clinical trials because we have less gender specific information yet heart disease causes death in more women than all cancers combined.  What are your thoughts?  Is there anything you wanted to know from our patient that didn't come out in her discussion?

8 comments:

  1. Before our discussion, I knew the differences in heart attack presentation between men and women and that heart disease was the number one killer of women. However, I did not realize women have a significantly worse outcome with the first heart attack compared to our male counterparts. I was extremely surprised by this piece of information and would love to know why such a difference exists.
    Again, I love our guest speakers that we have had over the last few weeks. Hearing individual stories places such a personal touch on a topic that is presented to us clinically. I think hearing about what symptoms a woman is experiencing (for months in this case) can really help us as future pharmacists; we now have a better chance at recognizing these symptoms in our patients and maybe we can help prevent some cardiovascular events.
    I’m glad we spent the time discussing heart disease since it does kill more women than all other cancers combined. I think our nation focuses so heavily on cancer research, prevention, and treatment that we forget about the common diseases that many women can prevent with simple lifestyle changes. Cancer awareness is definitely a positive and I don’t want to belittle these efforts, but it is also important to realize the risks women have regarding various disease states. Heart disease is almost completely preventable so why are we not doing more to prevent such a disease. I believe we, as women and as pharmacists, can play an important role to ensure our loved ones and our patients realize their risk for heart disease and ways to prevent its occurrence.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I was also surprised that there was such a worse outcome for women who have heart attacks. Is this because so many women are misdiagnosed at first presentation and suffer more heart damage before it is caught?
    I was very surprised by our guest speaker's story. It is shocking to hear that her heart disease was caused by a pulmonary infection that went untreated a little longer than it should have. I am one of those people that refuse to go to the doctor until I think I am dieing so her story was a little eyeopening.
    Her story as well as some of the other videos you posted were interesting to see how long women go enduring heart attacks before they are diagnosed. I was more under the impression that most people have more sudden cardiac arrest and are treated more quickly. I guess it goes to show how driven some women can get when taking care of families and careers.
    The only thing I still feel like I want more information on is the cases of 20 year olds dropping dead of sudden cardiac arrest. Is this a congenital defect that is exposed at a younger age due to the strain of their physicality? It seems to go totally against the physiology that we have been taught.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I also didn't realize that women have a worse outcome than males following the first heart attack. And although I do understand the differences in the way men and women present with a heart attack, I don't think that many women in the general population understand these differences. I think there needs to be better awareness for women that they may not experience symptoms like the classic left arm pain seen in males.
    Additionally, I think women need to realize that there are steps they can take early on to prevent or control heart disease. I thought it was interesting to hear the guest speaker talk about how she thought she was fine and didn't need to consider getting a pacemaker. I think health care professionals need to start stressing to women early on that just because they feel fine now doesn't mean that a serious cardiovascular event won't occur.
    I think more clinical trials involving women and heart disease need to occur. Since heart disease is the highest cause of death in women, we need more information about how to best treat women who present with heart issues, and how physicians can best recognize and diagnose a woman who is experiencing signs of a heart attack or potential heart problems. It really stood out to me that women may have to demand attention from multiple doctors before she can receive adequate medical attention and proper diagnosis. This is unacceptable, especially considering the prevalence of heart disease in women.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Like the girls mentioned above, I was not aware that women have worse outcomes when it comes to heart attacks. I think that that is an area where groups like Women Heart really can make a difference. Spreading the word on how common heart disease is could really make an impact. I feel like I understand the difference in presentation between men and women but what surprised me the most was that women often have radiating pain between their shoulder blades. I had never heard that and I think it is a very important symptom to counsel on. Perhaps this is due in part to the lack of female participants in clinical trials. It is important to consider this when interpreting data and make sure that as pharmacists we recognize the lack of information. I really liked hearing our guest speaker talk about her experience and as a side note I thought what she said about her dog saving her life was a miracle! The only thing I wish she would have had more time to talk about was her participation with WomenHeart. Overall I thought that this lecture was extremely informative and I feel like I learned a lot of useful information that I could share with patients.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I was surprised by the disparities between men and women and the treatment they receive (or don't receive) for the same condition. In one of the videos we watched, it was so disappointing to hear that woman's story about being discharged from the emergency room when a man who was complaining of the same chest pain, etc. was given cardiac care and being hooked up to a EKG machine, whereas the woman had to ask to be hooked up to one. I think the entire healthcare team needs to be re-educated as to the differences in presentation between men and women to prevent the delay that occurs in women receiving care since heart issues presents differently in women.

    I always enjoy hearing first-hand experiences from the patients; I think it really allows us to get the whole picture of the condition and better our care that we provide to these patients. I would have liked to hear more from our patient about her interactions with the pharmacist, what she would have wished her pharmacist could have done, and what should would want us to have said/done for a patient in her situation.

    I would also like to learn more about prevention and education regarding heart disease, including what things we can suggest to women of different ages. I'm also interested in educating women, especially younger women. Since this is the number one killer of women, I think it's best to educate women early so they can start incorporating little every day changes which can lead to big impacts on their overall health which can decrease their risk and hopefully change the statistics that surround heart disease.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I wasn’t aware that women present differently than men with heart disease. I was also not aware that heart disease could impact women at such a young age and even with pregnancy or complications with pregnancy. Usually after pregnancy, women are worried about their child and their needs, so raising awareness for this potential complication could be beneficial. I enjoyed watching the short video with Elizabeth Banks. It shows how many women could experience a heart attack and raises awareness to call for help when symptoms do appear.

    According to a consensus statement from WIN initiative, women only account for 20-25% of most heart disease clinical trials. That is surprisingly low considering 1 out of 3 women over the age of 20 has some form of cardiovascular disease. There has been a great push for awareness for heart disease in women, and so now there needs to be a push for research/clinical trials about heart disease or cardiovascular disease in women. In addition for a push for clinical trials, there needs to be a push for early interventions and screening for younger women. This could be incorporated into yearly wellness appointments for women starting at age 25. Doctors could hand out pamphlets or talk to women about the risks involved with heart risk as a women.

    After our discussion and hearing the different stories, I would be interested in seeing how many women are misdiagnosed when they present with symptoms that indicate heart disease. How many women have been misdiagnosed with indigestion or other health problems when the true problem is heart disease/heart attack?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I thought it was good to learn about women and heart disease since it is so common yet I think women in general are not aware of how common it is. Typically when you talk about heart attacks or heart disease you think of a male patient. I think it is good to get more awareness out about the signs and symptoms of heart attacks in how they present in women. I knew that it is more fatal when the case presents in a woman instead of a man, but I was not totally aware of the signs to look for in a woman. My grandfather died from congestive heart failure and his parents also died from heart attacks. However, I feel like my mom is not getting screened as much as she should since it is in her family. After hearing the stories in class, I feel like I can help her become more aware of what to look for in case of an emergency.

    I know that the FDA prohibits women from participating in clinical trials for heart disease. I know this is most likely due to the fact that the outcomes are worse in cases of women so it is not very ethical. However, this makes it difficult to decide what therapy would be the best to use. I wish there was a way to find better results to decrease the likelihood of heart disease in women without putting them at additional risk. I think the best way to start is by advocating the cause and hopefully one day we will have a better understanding of ways to prevent more heart attacks in women and find better ways to treat heart disease in women.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I need to clarify that there is no longer an FDA rule prohibiting women in clinical trails - it was removed in 1990's - sadly - we still are not doing much to increase our knowledge base.
      JHV

      Delete