Class #5: PCOS:
We discussed the pathophysiology and treatment of PCOS and
heard from a patient who has had the disorder for about 10 years. What are your
thoughts? What if you were suddenly afflicted with a disorder that increased
your weight by 50–100#?
Normal kids gather for Pizza and Soda (neither can be
considered as low carb options) How would that have affected your high school
and college friendships? What do you
think about this disorder that can affect diet choices, weight gain,
relationships and incur the “judgment” of by-standers? There are challenges to living with it but as
we understand it more – it is rarely associated with infertility when under
control. How do you keep from judging a "book by its cover"?? - it is a quick reflex by us all.
Do you understand Glycemic Index a bit better now? What
questions remain for you? What insights do you have?
I learned a lot from our discussion on PCOS last week. It amazed me to learn that this condition affects up to 20% of women. Until this point I was only aware that PCOS existed and knew next to nothing on how the condition developed and what treatment strategies are available. I think that its important that we as students push to have this included in our pharmacy curriculum so that we will be educated enough to provide recommendations and counseling for PCOS patients.
ReplyDeleteIf I learned that I had suddenly been diagnosed with PCOS, the weight gain would be a big concern, however, I would also be concerned with the excess hair growth. I feel that it would directly effect my self-esteem and most likely make me a lot more introverted than I am.
Most of the friends I made in college I made through cross country and track. If I had been diagnosed with PCOS it is unlikely I would have participated on the team. As far as social gatherings, it would be extremely difficult to go out for pizza or to a bar for drinks and be able to eat and drink what everyone else could without thinking about the effect on my weight.
I think that PCOS has just as much effect on the "inside" as it does on the outside. There is the weight gain, hair growth, and acne, however what moved me the most was the constant struggle that Rachel went through to get to where she is today. The depression is something that I feel I would have the hardest time overcoming, especially because currently there is no cure for PCOS. As pharmacists it is important for us to understand the indications of different medications so that we do not jump the the most common conclusion when dispensing and counseling. Now that I am aware that metformin is also indicated for PCOS I will be sure to clarify why the patient is taking this medication before assuming she is diabetic. This was an extremely useful class and I think it should definitely be included in the Therapeutics curriculum.
Finally, I just wanted to thank Rachel for talking so openly with the class. I found her to be very inspiring. After hearing her speak to the class I had a better appreciation for the difficulties a woman living with PCOS goes through.
I was really shocked to hear how prevalent PCOS is. I had never really heard much about this condition, and to learn that about 1 in 10 women have it and, according to the pcosfoundation.org, less than 50% are diagnosed. From the mystery diagnosis videos and various articles/stories I've read, I find it frustrating that doctors often seem to overlook this diagnosis. The fact that it is also not in our curriculum is a little frustrating as well. It is a prevalent condition, patients are on multiple medications, and these patients could be found in any of our practice settings, making it a very relevant topic for pharmacists.
ReplyDeleteThis condition requires such a lifestyle change (managing your medications, managing your weight, fitting in time to exercise, etc. ) and I honestly can't imagine dealing with it at any age, but especially not in my teenage/college years. This is such a difficult time for girls, and to have the substantial weight gain and hair growth would indescribably complicate all of the challenges she is facing during that time when you're trying to find yourself and you're heavily influenced by other people and what they think of you. Even as I look back on my struggles with weight and self-confidence during these years, that doesn't even compare to what girls with PCOS have to go through. And especially during college when you're faced with fast food, late night pizza, alcohol -- all these poor food choices constantly surround you. I think it would be extremely hard to have put on a lot of weight and always being surrounded by these bad influences. Plus, you have to see everyone around you partake in them without gaining weight while you limit yourself and still end up with the substantial weight gain. I would feel so defeated by everything. Plus, during your teenage/college years, gaining weight at all seems like the end of the world. Hearing stories about PCOS and weight gain sure makes a pound gained here and there seem so insignificant…
Plus, along with the weight gain comes complete lifestyle changes - having to make sure you fit in time to exercise, watching what you eat, calculating the glycemic index of your meals. It definitely complicates everyday life. I also had never really paid attention to the glycemic index before class. I was surprised to see how unhealthy some of my food choices are once I considered them in this context. Usually if I pay attention to what I'm eating, I base it off of calories, but that's only one side of the coin... Pretzels seemed like a healthier snack to me until seeing where they fell on the glycemic index…
I am still curious as to the outlook of this condition. Is there a difference depending on how soon/what age you are diagnosed and get treated? If you are able to lose the weight, does it just keep coming back? Are you able to decrease your medications as time goes on or do the doses pretty much remain the same for life?
I admire Rachel for being so candid about her experience with PCOS. I think having someone with the condition tell us about her real life experience helped put things into perspective, and to be able to see it from the patient's point of view was really beneficial.
Like the other girls have mentioned, I knew next to nothing about PCOS and how many women are affected by this disease. Our discussion and Rachel’s honesty helped me to gain a better appreciation for the daily struggles and lifestyle adjustments that are necessary when diagnosed with PCOS. While I have struggled with weight and self-esteem through my teens and early twenties (what girl doesn’t), I believe PCOS would have made my life ten times tougher. The weight gain is enough of a struggle but the excess body hair and acne associated with PCOS would make growing up a nightmare. Kids are cruel enough as it is but adding on a disease that causes so many unwanted physical changes makes the situation unbearable. It’s completely understandable why so many women with PCOS require an anti-depressant of some sort to help them through the day; I would certainly need one if I was in their shoes.
ReplyDeleteSelf-esteem is not the only aspect of life that would take a beating if a young woman was diagnosed with PCOS. The last ten years or so of my life, my friends and I would use meals/eating as a method of socializing. Eating out and going to bars are the main times that I can catch up with a friend and learn about what is going on in his or her life. Having PCOS would make this form of socialization extremely difficult; you can’t eat what your friends are eating and you cannot indulge in alcohol and desserts like everyone can. Even if you do watch what you are eating, chances are you still won’t be able to lose weight or be a size 4; how unfair is that! I also think Katie brings up a good point – the lifestyle changes are another tough aspect of PCOS. Trying to fit an exercise schedule around classes, homework, and socialization is tough enough for the average college student. Also, most college students take one pill or less a day; women with PCOS are practically a pharmacy at age 20! I can barely remember to take a multivitamin as it is.
Tuesday’s class also taught me a great deal about glycemic index. I knew what glycemic index meant but I was unaware of where many foods fall on the glycemic index scale. The “choose this, not that” part of class was extremely helpful for me; now I know which foods are going to burn slower and provide a larger amount of energy. I don’t think our classes so far have done an adequate job of teaching us how to help patients, like Rachel, choose healthy food options so I greatly appreciated this part of the class.
As the other girls have said,I was completely unaware of the high prevalence of PCOS. I didn't even understand the basic pathophysiology, and I think it's an injustice both to us as future pharmacists and our future patients that the vast majority of our pharmacy class will still be in the dark about PCOS upon completing classes. I agree that it is a topic that should be addressed in our regular curriculum. After class last week, I was telling the pharmacist that I work with that we had discussed PCOS in class, and that it was the first time we had really learned about the topic. His response was, "Well, it's not very common". I was glad to be able to correct him and explain more about disorder.
ReplyDeleteMany teenage and 20-something women struggle with their weight and self-esteem, as we have previously discussed. A woman with PCOS also struggles with the potential consequences of a disorder that she first becomes informed about during these challenging years of life. And in addition to that, she has to deal with sudden weight gain that occurs for a reason out of her control. This would be very difficult for any woman to handle. I think it's very important for us, especially as health care professionals, to not judge a book by its cover.
I can understand how modifying your diet due to a disorder is difficult. My sister has a rare condition, which she was diagnosed with 4 years ago, that requires her to eliminate all oils and fats from her diet. She was 13 when she received this diagnosis, and the changes she had to make to her diet and lifestyle were huge. I know it's been really hard for her, especially when with friends, to pass on the pizza or ice cream because it isn't a good choice for her to remain healthy. This is very similar to the dilemma that women with PCOS face. These patients are often diagnosed at such a young age, but it's not something that these patients have dealt with their whole lives, and I think that probably makes the whole adjustment even more difficult, because they know what they're missing.
I already knew quite a bit about glycemic index, but I still appreciated learning more about it and how it's used by patients with PCOS. One thing that struck me is the glycemic index of a normal baked potato compared to a sweet potato. So many people focus diet changes based only on calories, and I think it's good for us as pharmacists to know how other factors like glycemic index can play a huge role in certain patient's diet goals.
I thought this was a great disease state to learn about since it affects so many women. I knew very little information on PCOS before our class. Therefore, I felt like I really have a good knowledge now on the topic in case this ever were to present to me through patients. I cannot image what it would be like to be a teenage girl and suddenly gain a bunch of weight. I think it would be very difficult to adapt to the new lifestyle as a young girl. Like you mentioned, most girls that age eat junk food and really do not worry about counting calories. Therefore, it would hard to say no to eating the pizza or anything else. At that age, all you really want to do is be young and have fun. You do not want to worry about what you have to eat and exercise. I was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes my sophomore year of college, and had to adjust to counting carbs and eating better. However, it still is not the same as having to say no to all unhealthy foods. Like you said in class, if I wanted to pizza all I have to do is up my dose of insulin; whereas, someone with PCOS cannot do that. It would be a huge life change, and I understand why depression is often seen in these cases.
ReplyDeleteBefore class I knew about the glycemic index and which foods are better to eat than others. I feel like the power point you showed us was a very good way to describe how to use the glycemic index and picking healthy choices. It was a good refresher course for me, and I do feel like I even learned some information on different foods that I was unaware of which was worse for you. I felt like this portion of the class was a good way for me even help choose healthier options while I am trying to diet now.
Overall, I cannot believe how common PCOS is in the United States. For my own statistical purposes, I brought up this topic to friends and family to see if they knew of anyone that has PCOS. I was amazed by how many people said they knew someone who has it. One of my friends even said, "isn't that the disease where you can't have children?" It made me realize that many people do not know the true facts about PCOS, and I think Butler should teach a lecture on this topic since it is so common and to help spread the true facts about PCOS.
I had never heard of PCOS before last Tuesday, so I’m glad this was a topic chosen for this class. There is so much awareness for cervical cancer, heart disease, and many other complications in women, so I think it would be important to add PCOS to that list. Many girls struggle with body image issues so gaining 50-100 lbs would be difficult to deal with. I think it would have made grade school and high school a lot more challenging if I had such a drastic change in weight. The weight gain alone could be a reason for other kids/students to make fun of you. Then you add all the other complications of PCOS including acne and hair growth…it’s like the perfect storm.
ReplyDeleteI think having PCOS and trying to adjust to college life would be pretty difficult. Thinking back at what food options were offered my freshman and sophomore year…the number of unhealthy options was greater than the number of healthy options. This would make it even more challenging trying to manage weight. I think that it’s especially hard in college to not judge a book by its cover when you are meeting a bunch of new people in a short amount of time. If we were able to get more awareness for PCOS, I think there would be a lot of girls and women out there who could benefit. It would be interesting to see how many more girls and women would be diagnosed with PCOS if awareness was increased.
After learning more about how common it is in women, it’s surprising that we aren’t taught about it in pharmacy school. Pharmacists could play a big role in making the lives of women with PCOS more manageable.